The Battle of Meat Pies vs Mince Pies: Which One is Better?

In the UK, there is a rivalry between the traditional Christmas pies – mince pies and meat pies. The debate over which one is better has been going on for years. Which one should you be eating this Christmas?

On the one hand, a good mince pie is always a welcome treat during the holiday season. They are typically covered in flaky pastry and filled with spiced fruit. On the other hand, a great meat pie can’t be matched either.

They’re made from ground meat that’s been blended with other ingredients to create a filling that’s perfect as an accompaniment to a pint of ale or as a stand-alone snack. In all honesty, it’s hard to pick which one is better! But we do have our preferences.

Some people often confuse Mince pies with MINCED MEAT pies which is understandable.

What is a mince pie?

Mince pies are a Christmas-time tradition in Britain. They are typically made from minced fruit, spices, and brandy or another type of spirit. The mincemeat is usually enclosed in a sweet pie crust.

What is a meat pie?

What is a meat pie? A meat pie is made from ground meat, other ingredients. The meat mixture is then cooked in a pie crust before being served. Typically served with tomato sauce. aka Ketchup.

The Battle of Meat Pies vs Mince Pies

So, which is better? We will let you decide for yourself. But there are some things to consider when making your decision. One thing that can help you decide is the size of each pie. The mince pie is typically bigger than the meat pie. If you’re hosting a party this Christmas, or just want to feed your family a hearty meal on Christmas day, then you might want to go with the mince pie.

Another thing to consider when making that decision is how filling each kind of pie is. A meat pie has a mixture of ingredients in it that will keep you feeling full for hours after eating it. Of course, a mince pie also has some fruit in it too which also makes it more filling than a meat pie on its own.

Who should you be eating this Christmas?

If you’re looking for something sweet, go for the mince pie. It has a spiced fruit filling that will satisfy your cravings. If you’re looking for something savory, then it’s hard to beat a meat pie. You can enjoy them with a pint of ale or by themselves as a snack.

At the end of the day, both pies are delicious and have their own merits. However, if it were up to us, we’d eat both! Mince pies are great during the holiday season because they are so festive with all their flaky pastry and spiced fruit filling. Meat pies are perfect when you need something savory during the holidays too since they have ground meat in them.


Who doesn’t love the mouthwatering taste of a hot mince pie over the cold, dry taste of a meat pie? Well it turns out that you don’t have to choose one or the other because you can have both. And it’s not just about which is better, it’s also about how to enjoy them like a true native.